The Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario (the IPC) received a privacy complaint from a children’s aid society about the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) disclosing personal information contrary to the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FIPPA or the Act). The children’s aid society stated that the OPP had implemented new reporting system software (Child Protection Agency Notification Plug-in) and since that time, had sent several occurrence reports in which a youth was listed a witness or victim of a serious crime, but where there was no indication of a child protection concern. The children’s aid society stated that the OPP should not send reports absent a child protection concern, and that to do so was a breach of the youth’s privacy. The IPC opened a Commissioner-initiated privacy complaint file against the Ministry of the Solicitor General (the ministry), the ministry responsible for the OPP, regarding the use of the reporting system noted above.
In this report, I find that the guidance the ministry provided for use of the Child Protection Agency Notification Plug-in is contrary to section 125 of the Child, Youth, and Family Services Act (CYFSA) and section 42 of FIPPA. Section 125 of the CYFSA sets out a number of harms or risks to children and imposes a duty to report in cases where an individual, including an OPP officer, has reasonable grounds to suspect one or more of those harms or risks. The guidance provided by the ministry requires officers to send a report to a children’s aid society in all cases where a youth is listed as a victim or witness to a serious crime. Mandating these disclosures, rather than having the officer use their judgment as to whether a duty to report exists under section 125 of the CYFSA, allows for the possibility that the OPP may disclose personal information to a children’s aid society when there is no duty to report, which would be contrary to the Act. I recommend that the ministry change its guidance to reflect that officers are to send reports to a children’s aid society when the officer judges they have a duty to report, and to remove guidance stating that such reports are mandatory when a youth is listed as a victim or a witness.